A Comparison Of Montana 1948 And Twelve Angry Men - 798 Words

Write a detailed comparison of how montana 1948 and twelve angry men present ideas, issues and themes. Suggested Length: 700-800 words. Compare the way the two texts explore this ideas. Larry Watson’s 1993 novella ‘Montana 1948’ tells a tale of loyalty and justice through a young boy living in a town where the justice system is corrupted by family ties and racism. Likewise, in Reginald Rose’s 1954 teleplay ‘Twelve Angry Men’, twelve jurors determine the fate of a boy accused of murdering his father. Although the stories are quite different, Montana 1948 having a strong family dynamic and Twelve Angry Men being a short courtroom drama, ultimately they both explore justice as a theme and how justice can be very subjective and moulded to†¦show more content†¦This links in with justice as what one person defines as absolute and correct may seem completely irrational to another person, much like how Wes Hayden, Frank’s brother, believes his brother is wrongdoing while Frank believes his crimes are somewhat justified. The issue of morality is a dominant theme in both texts, providing a central and critical theme in the narrative arc. In ‘Montana 1948’, Wes is conflicted when he hears about his brother’s rape accusations and is unsure whether to stand by his his family and ignore all the accusations or pursue morale justice against his brother’s actions at the expense of his family name. A similar situation arises in ‘Twelve Angry Men’ when the jurors take their initial vote and only one of the 12 jurors, the 3rd juror, takes a moral stance and is prepared to fight for justice by voting ‘not guilty’ due to the doubt present and lack of evidence available. He decides to take the moral high ground choosing to analyse the evidence before giving his conviction, claiming that he can’t possible â€Å"send a boy off to die† without at least â€Å"talking about it first†, thus considering the fate of the boy and the moral decision he must make. Despite criticisms and anger faced by other jurors, he reasons with them in a civil manner before agreeing that there is reasonable doubt to the accuracy of the evidence of whetherShow MoreRelatedDeveloping Management Skills404131 Words   |  1617 PagesSUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL 24 Diagnostic Survey and Exercises 24 Personal Assessment of Management Skills (PAMS) 24 What Does It Take to Be an Effective Manager? 28 SSS Software In-Basket Exercise 30 SCORING KEY AND COMPARISON DATA 42 Personal Assessment of Management Skills 42 Scoring Key 42 Comparison Data 42 What Does It Take to Be an Effective Manager? 43 SSS Software In-Basket Exercise 43 PART I 1 PERSONAL SKILLS 44 45 DEVELOPING SELF-AWARENESS SKILL ASSESSMENT 46 Diagnostic Surveys for